Difference between revisions of "Talk:Quicklime"
(→Change redirect to Mannworks (Quicklime Factory): new section) |
|||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
In my opinion, short of making an article for Mann Co. Quicklime (probably unwarranted), the [[Quicklime]] redirect should redirect to wherever the subject is most deeply discussed, which presently is [[Mannworks]]. Mann Co. Quicklime makes several appearances in the game and in background content; the Voodoo-Cursed Bag of Quicklime Item is just one minor appearance. [[Sticky bomb]] does not redirect to [[Voodoo-Cursed Sticky-Bomb]]. [[Robot]] does not redirect to [[Voodoo-Cursed Robot Arm]]. The [[Quicklime]] redirect should be changed to redirect to Mannworks, then the [[Voodoo-Cursed Bag of Quicklime]] article should then be linked to from Mannworks in either Trivia or See also sections, or in the main text. [[User:Mikado282|Mikado282]] ([[User talk:Mikado282|talk]]) 17:36, 25 May 2014 (PDT) | In my opinion, short of making an article for Mann Co. Quicklime (probably unwarranted), the [[Quicklime]] redirect should redirect to wherever the subject is most deeply discussed, which presently is [[Mannworks]]. Mann Co. Quicklime makes several appearances in the game and in background content; the Voodoo-Cursed Bag of Quicklime Item is just one minor appearance. [[Sticky bomb]] does not redirect to [[Voodoo-Cursed Sticky-Bomb]]. [[Robot]] does not redirect to [[Voodoo-Cursed Robot Arm]]. The [[Quicklime]] redirect should be changed to redirect to Mannworks, then the [[Voodoo-Cursed Bag of Quicklime]] article should then be linked to from Mannworks in either Trivia or See also sections, or in the main text. [[User:Mikado282|Mikado282]] ([[User talk:Mikado282|talk]]) 17:36, 25 May 2014 (PDT) | ||
| + | :Quite honestly, an item should take priority over a map in a case like this, seeing as how the item's name ''directly'' mentions quicklime. Your examples are also somewhat farfetched, considering how sticky bombs and robots are much bigger game mechanics than quicklime. I'm gonna go and make it into a disambig. [[File:User Zabidenu sig.png|link=User:Zabidenu]] <small>([[Special:Contribs/Zabidenu|contribs]] ▪ [[User talk:Zabidenu|talk]])</small> 17:48, 25 May 2014 (PDT) | ||
Revision as of 00:48, 26 May 2014
Change redirect to Mannworks (Quicklime Factory)
In my opinion, short of making an article for Mann Co. Quicklime (probably unwarranted), the Quicklime redirect should redirect to wherever the subject is most deeply discussed, which presently is Mannworks. Mann Co. Quicklime makes several appearances in the game and in background content; the Voodoo-Cursed Bag of Quicklime Item is just one minor appearance. Sticky bomb does not redirect to Voodoo-Cursed Sticky-Bomb. Robot does not redirect to Voodoo-Cursed Robot Arm. The Quicklime redirect should be changed to redirect to Mannworks, then the Voodoo-Cursed Bag of Quicklime article should then be linked to from Mannworks in either Trivia or See also sections, or in the main text. Mikado282 (talk) 17:36, 25 May 2014 (PDT)
- Quite honestly, an item should take priority over a map in a case like this, seeing as how the item's name directly mentions quicklime. Your examples are also somewhat farfetched, considering how sticky bombs and robots are much bigger game mechanics than quicklime. I'm gonna go and make it into a disambig.
(contribs ▪ talk) 17:48, 25 May 2014 (PDT)
